1 - 3oz.box jello mix for each colorwe used 6 colors: cherry, orange, pineapple, lime, blue berry, and grape
1cupboiling water per flavor
½cupMalibu coconut rum per flavor
½cupcold water per flavor
White Jello Layers Ingredients
1.5oz.clear gelatin6 x .25 oz. packets
3 - 14oz.sweetened canned condensed milk
6cupswater
Garnish
whipped creamoptional
Airhead rainbow candies or rainbow sprinklesoptional
Instructions
Combine the packet of purple Jell-O and 1 cup of boiling water in a bowl. Whisk until Jell-O is fully dissolved in the boiling water.
In a 2-cup measuring cup, pour in ½ cup - ¾ cup of Malibu rum. Add cold water to the 1 cup measurement line. (Depending on how strong you’d like the jell-o shots, adjust the amount of Malibu and then add water as needed to make 1 cup total of liquid).
Add the rum and the cold water to the grape Jell-O mixture.
Pour the Jell-O mixture to fill an extremely thin layer in the bottom of plastic shot glasses (about 1 teaspoon per layer. Please note: if you are using tapered cups, you will use less liquid in the bottom layers to create the same thickness of layer - so you may be using only ½ teaspoon for the first couple layers and then gradually up to 1 teaspoon for the final layers. Set the shot glasses inside the refrigerator for about 30 minutes to chill and set. (The Jell-O layers set quickly because they are so thin.)
After about 30 minutes, mix together the white layer. We’ll do the ingredients for the white Jell-O ⅓ at a time so that you don’t have to mix it up all at once and manage such a large quantity. The Jell-O will stay liquid at room temp or with a few seconds in the microwave, so you CAN mix it all at once, but we prefer to do ⅓ at a time.
For ⅓ of the total white Jell-O: Sprinkle two packets of clear gelatin over 1 cup of cold water in a heat-proof bowl or measuring cup. Whisk together and set aside for 5 minutes to allow the gelatin to bloom. Place in the microwave for 15 seconds and then whisk to dissolve the gelatin completely. Add 1 cup of cold water and 1 full can (14 oz.) of sweetened, condensed milk. Whisk to fully combine the ingredients. Check that the mixture is room temperature. If it is warm at all, place the white Jell-O mixture into the refrigerator or allow to cool to room temperature.
Add a very thin layer (about ½ teaspoon) of the white Jell-O mixture over the purple layer. Return Jell-O shots to the refrigerator to chill until set (another 15-30 minutes.)
Mix the next layer of Jell-O just as you did with the purple. Dissolve blue Jell-O in 1 cup of boiling water. Mix Malibu and cold water to make an additional 1 cup of liquid and combine with the blue Jell-O. Once cooled to room temperature, add your thin layer of blue Jell-O over the white layer.
Continue adding white layers of Jell-O and colored layers until you finish with the final red layer of Jell-O. As you use up all of the white Jell-O mixture, follow the same process as Step 5 to make another batch. IF you use all of the Jell-O from each color (96 Jell-O shots), you will need about 3 batches of white Jell-O.
Whip heavy cream or use canned whipped cream to top the Jell-O shots JUST BEFORE SERVING. Add a ¾-1” strip of Airheads rainbow candy or top with colorful sprinkles.
Would you like to save this?
We'll email this recipe to you, so you can come back to it later!
Notes
The white Jell-O mixture needs to be cooled COMPLETELY before pouring over the colored layers or it will melt the layer underneath and the colors will swirl together.
Be sure each subsequent color of Jell-O is cooled to room temperature also before pouring over the white layer underneath.
If you use tapered shot glasses, you will need slightly more Jell-O for the top layers than the bottom layers. I took a Sharpie and drew lines to divide one cup into 11 sections (adjust if you’re not using 6 different colors of Jell-O). This gave me a good idea of about how much Jell-O to pour for each layer. It’s not much. Using a ½ teaspoon or a single teaspoon works well to maintain control and not overpour. Remember, these don't have to be perfect. They taste good whether the layers are perfectly even or not.
Because we’re pouring such thin layers of Jell-O and using so many colors, this recipe will make about 96 Jell-O shots!! If you want to make less, simply fill the number of cups you want to make with each color Jell-O. Then, pour the remaining Jell-O into a greased square baking dish. Refrigerate the baking dish (be sure it is completely level) as you refrigerate the Jell-O shots. Skip the white layers in between each color (which will save you ingredients) and just add the leftover subsequent Jell-O as you work to fill the cups. Then, you will have a pan of rainbow layered Jell-O as well. (Remember that you’ve added liquor to the Jell-O, so maybe don’t just dig in with a big spoon.) You can cut the pan of Jell-O into small squares for serving.